Israel: Bookworm or Maggot?

This piece was also published in Allvoices.

Israel: Bookworm or Maggot?
By Roi Ben-Yehuda

Israel is a bookish country. Its historical roots are traced in a book; its people have been called the “people of the book”; and its founding father, Theodore Herzl, a playwright, liked to write books.

There is something literary, even fantastical, about the existence of Israel. Who else but a playwright would have thought it possible to bring to life a 2000-year-old wish? To revive a people and their disused language? And to transform a barren landscape and make a desert bloom?

One of my favorite facts about Israel is that it leads the world in per-capita new book titles per year. Over 4000 titles a year. Not just any book titles – works by such literary luminaries as Amos Oz, David Grossman, Abraham Yehoshua, Etgar Keret, Aharon Appelfeld, Anton Shammas and Sayed Kashua.

By any measurable criteria, Israel is a bookworm’s fantasy. Yet, to an increasing number of persons around the world, Israel is, metaphorically speaking, more like a maggot than it is a bookworm.

The ‘Israel is a maggot’ crowd has recently come out in protest over Italy’s decision to honor Israel’s cultural achievements at this year’s Turin International Book Fair. Lead by theologian Tariq Ramadan and pundit Tariq Ali, left-wing Italian intellectuals, and Muslim authors in the Diaspora and Arab world have called for a boycott of the event.

The justifications given in favor of the boycott are of two kinds: The first unequivocally rejects the celebration of Israel in its totality. The idea being that as long as Israel is an occupying power, as long as it continues in its aggression toward the Palestinians, it should not be a “guest of honor” in any event.

In a letter to the organizers of Book Fair, Ramadan gives voice to this notion when he writes that: “To choose the State of Israel while you know what was, and still is, happening in the occupied territories – and just after the international community, almost unanimously, condemned the Gaza’s blockage – is neither wise nor fair towards the Palestinian and their dignity.”

The second argument in favor of the boycott rests on the idea that since Israelis and Palestinians are attached at the hip, authors from both nations should have been invited. Moreover, to not do so, to honor Israel at 60 without giving equal weight to the significance that Palestinians accord the same date – the 60th anniversary of the Nakba (Arabic for catastrophe)- is to validate Israel’s maltreatment of the Palestinians.

Both of these arguments seem to me to be misguided. The first one, ‘no honor for an occupying power’, fails to differentiate between the subject and the state, between an artist and their state. To the likes of Ramadan it does not matter who is invited to represent Israel’s cultural achievements. If their passport says “Israel” then they represent the actions of their government. In this regard their logic is no that different than a terrorist who says that every Israeli, no matter where he lives or how he votes, represents the policies of the state and is therefore fair game.

In an open letter to Ramadan, Ernesto Ferrero and Rolando Picchio, Director and President of the Book Fair, accused Ramadan of a making a categorical mistake – of confusing the purpose of art and politics. The fair did not invite politicians, they reasoned, it invited artists. The whole mission of art transcends the political and rises to the level of the universal and timeless.

“The reasons of literature and those of politics have always been deeply different and often radically conflicting. Politics think about the “here and now” while literature talks to men of all times and all Countries. It does not divide, but brings together.

With respect to this position, it seems to me that it is precisely because art is not divorced from the political that those who call for a boycott are wrong. Art is not separated from politics – art is the intersection of the political with the sublime; the marriage of the time-bound and the timeless.

The irony here is that by calling for a boycott of the book fair, Ramadan and his ilk are alienating and hurting the one group of people that were in their corner in the first place. After all, it is the artist in Israeli society that serves the function of the proverbial gadfly – the critical voice of dissent that challenges Israel’s leaders and people to be held accountable for their actions. They are also the vanguard of Israel’s peace movement – the few voices calling for peace that command the respect of Israeli society.

The second argument, ‘if you honor Israel you must also honor Palestine’ is more attractive than the first but in the end also fails to compel. The idea being that if you shine a light on Israel, you are bound to get the shadow of Palestine (the reverse also being true). Since the histories of the two people are so intertwined, the argument goes, to honor one without recognizing the other is to commit an injustice.

Of course there is nothing wrong with the idea of honoring the cultures of both Israel and Palestine – on the contrary, it is a terrific idea. It would have been prudent and sensitive of the organizers to have invited on this occasion both Palestinian and Israeli authors. To create, as Tariq Ali put it, “a literary version of Daniel Barenboim’s Diwan Orchestra, half-Israeli, half-Palestinian.” But alas they did not. And their choice, while perhaps myopic, is perfectly valid and not unjust.

The point here is that Palestine is not Israel’s shadow, and should not follow it wherever it goes. As an independent country, Israel has every right to be recognized on its own. It is a disservice to both Israelis and Palestinians to think otherwise.

Rolando Picchioni, President of the foundation that runs the event, answered this criticism best when said:“A country has to be able to come to the fair without being counterbalanced by another country. What’s next: If we honor Russia, do we also have to invite Chechnya? Or what about China. Do we bring in Tibet?”

Finally, I am quite certain that if the reverse were true, if Palestinian artists were honored at this year’s book fair, the same intellectual activists who are now calling for a boycott would not be arguing for the inclusion of Israel. Nor would they have argued that the inhuman policies conducted by Hamas (who until recently was represented in Palestinian government) necessitate a boycott of Palestine as a guest of honor. I am also sure that there would not be a single Israeli artist calling for a boycott of the event based on the grounds that honoring these artist is like honoring Hamas.

For all of its shortcomings (and the list is long), when it comes to art and culture, Israel has a lot to show for itself. To boycott the honoring of Israel at the Turin International Book Fair is a pathetic attempt to deligitimize the existence and accomplishments of the Jewish state. Instead of rejecting the event all together, instead of saying that Israel should not be honored, the boycotters would do well to attend the event, listen to what the Israeli authors have to say, and engage in dialogue and debate.

After all, is not communication, the reaching out of one soul to another, the raison d’être of books in the first place?

5 responses to “Israel: Bookworm or Maggot?

  1. This is the kind of thing that makes me think that Israel’s problems will be eternal. No matter what comes up, even something as innocent as a book fair, the issue always comes back to the legitimacy of the Israeli state. It’s like there’s a drop of mud in every fresh glass of water that’s poured.

    Am I a pessimist, or do people in Israel feel the same way?

    Oh, before I forget, can I ask you a wee little favor, Roi? Can you translate my novel into Hebrew so that somebody in Israel will publish it? I’ll take you out to lunch.

  2. Take me out to lunch, huh? Sounds like a deal. But we are not going to eat at that corpse restaurant again, are we?

  3. Btw, sorry for the old version of this article, I did not realize that the whole thing was pasted incorrectly.

  4. nice how you have shown your passion for books in this article.

    Words, as music, danse, paintings, architecture 🙂 … can help oneself to underestand, to respect, to learn and love the “other”

  5. Michael Kalmanovitz


    On Monday 31 March over two dozen people picketed the Italian Embassy in London with placards, banners and loudhailers, calling for a boycott of the Turin Book Fair, which has invited Israel as the “guest of honour”.

    Protesters were appalled that the President of the Italian Republic has added his weight to this decision by publicising his intention to open this Book Fair on May 8, even though this is in the week of Nakba – the 60th anniversary of the ethnic cleansing of Palestinian people by the Israeli state.

    Jewish anti-Zionist women and men in the Global Women’s Strike and Payday men’s network, who called the picket, and activists from Jews for Boycotting Israeli Goods (J-BIG) and Camden – Abu Dis Friendship Association (CADFA) were vocal in their denunciation of Israel’s deputy defence minister Vilnai’s call for a “shoah” – a holocaust – against people in Gaza. A speaker from the Utility Workers Union of America (AFL-CIO) decried that the AFL leadership had helped support and finance the occupation.

    Anti-Book Fair demonstrations at the weekend in Turin, Rome & Milan were reported to the picket. Over 700 people had rallied in Turin’s main square, with street theatre and a photo exhibition; and there were sit-ins at Feltrinelli bookshops in Milan and Rome because they announced that they would take part in the Book Fair. The police attacked the demonstrators in Milan following an afternoon of provocation by Zionists, who tried to tear up one of the banners.

    Representatives of the London picket tried to deliver a letter of protest to the Ambassador, but the carabiniere representing the Embassy said that the Ambassador would not accept the letter without an appointment! A demonstrator commented on her loudhailer that “They’d rather welcome Israeli Zionists!”

    Demonstrators, who were also from Canada, Egypt, Germany, Iran, Israel, Italy, New Zealand, Sweden, Turkey and the US, were incensed at the Ambassador’s refusal and declared that they would contact their networks to flood the Embassy with letters.
    Please email this letter or write your own to the Italian Embassy in your country.
    Please CC the Global Women’s Strike & Payday men’s network
    For the list of Italian Embassies check

    We protest against the outrageous decision of the Turin Book Fair to make Israel its “guest of honour”. If this decision to invite and honour Israel is not rescinded, the Book Fair must be boycotted.

    The invitation has sinister echoes in the UK: on 7 April Prince Philip hosted a dinner in Windsor Castle for the Jewish National Fund, a key Zionist organisation that has dispossessed & expelled Palestinian people from their lands.

    We find it all the more astonishing that President of the Italian Republic Giorgio Napolitano plans to open the Fair on 8 May considering that the Fair’s President, Rolando Picchioni, was a member of the Masonic Lodge P2, led by Lucio Gelli, who was not only a fervent admirer of the Fascist leader Mussolini, but a liaison officer with the Hermann Goering SS division. In the ‘70s the P2 infamously planned a right-wing coup d’état in Italy.

    Those of who are Jewish are particularly outraged that the Israeli State is so eager to take a part in the fair organized by an old associate of Nazis. This collaboration, however, is less surprising following Israel’s deputy defence minister Vilnai’s Nazi call for a “shoah” – a holocaust – against people in Gaza.

    Calling for a boycott in response to inviting the Israeli State to the Paris & Turin Book Fairs, Israeli poet Aharon Shabtai said:

    “The book event, or any other kind of exhibition in which the Israeli State is invited, is not a way to promote peace in the Middle East, and not a way to bring justice to the Palestinians, but only propaganda to give Israel an image of being a liberal & democratic society. A State which maintains an occupation & commits daily crimes against civilians does not deserve to be invited to whichever cultural week.”

    The Union of Palestinian Writers & Intellectuals has also called for a boycott. And there are protests, demonstrations & boycott demands planned throughout Italy: on 5th February the headquarters of organizers of the Fair, Fondazione del Libro, was occupied; Italian book publishers have launched an appeal; a petition is being circulated & signed internationally by MEPs, students, workers, teachers & prominent individuals; demonstrations took place in Turin, Milan and Rome on 29th March; and your embassy was picketed on 31st March.

    For the organisers of the Book Fair to honour Israel in the week before Nakba is not only a provocation but also a disgraceful defence of the murder, rape & torture that is the Israeli occupation.

    This occupation is one with the occupation of Iraq: military control of oil & water in the Middle East for the real axis of evil – US, Israel & their European stooges. And now the Italian authorities have shown they are complicit in the additional crime of Nakba denial.
    Global Women’s Strike 020 7482 2496
    Payday men’s network 020 7209 4751

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s